Morcellation Device Maker Threatens to Sue Doctor For Warning of Dangers

Monday, September 8, 2014

For the past several months, DrugNews has reported on growing concerns that power morcellator devices used in many hysterectomies could spread uterine cancer.

Since April, the FDA has launched an investigation and advised doctors of potential risks. The largest manufacturer of the devices has also stopped selling them for the time being.

Now, however, the doctor that started the public awareness campaign over hysterectomy device cancer dangers could face legal action from a company that isn’t happy about the prospect of losing sales.

Last year, Dr. Amy Reed, an anesthesiologist from Massachusetts, learned that she had advanced stage uterine sarcoma after undergoing a hysterectomy. Since then, she and her husband Dr. Noorchashm have warned of the risks of power morcellators.

Morcellation devices allow doctors to perform laparoscopic surgeries with much smaller incisions than normal, speeding recovery times, reducing scars and limiting the risk of infection after surgery.

However, the tiny blades can also spread tissue as they cut. The FDA has warned that as many as 1 in 350 women that undergo the procedures could have undetected uterine cancer, which can be substantially accelerated.

Dr. Noorchashm’s campaign included writing letters to other doctors, health regulators and the manufacturers of the devices themselves, asking that they be pulled from the market.

In July, Johnson & Johnson, the largest maker of power morcellators, announced they would no longer sell them. However, German manufacturer Karl Storz is not happy about all the negative attention.

Karl Storz made the device used in Dr. Reed’s fibroid removal. Now, they have written Dr. Noorchashm demanding that he stop warning of cancer dangers and blaming them for his wife’s case.

He says he will continue to warn the public about morcellators, and push for an end to their usage.

Lawyers have also begun filing lawsuits against morcellator makers on behalf of those affected by cancer. Until recently, no one warned patients of this serious risk.



Lowes, R. Morcellation Critic Dares Device Maker on Lawsuit Threat. MedScape. (September 4, 2014). Retrieved from


Other drugs and devices in the news:

Friday, August 9, 2019
Surgical Stapler
Did Surgical Staple Companies Hide Thousands of Injuries?

This past spring, the FDA issued a warning affecting the millions of patients each year that undergo routine gastrointestinal, gynecologic...

Friday, August 2, 2019
Invokana Gangrene Amputation
Federal Panel Adds Fournier's Gangrene to Crowded Invokana MDL Court

In the latest Invokana lawsuit update, DrugNews has learned that a federal judicial panel has transferred new cases alleging...

Get in touch with us.

Call, email or live chat with us today to see how we can help.

Need a quick answer? Call us!
Reach out to us by email.
live chat with DrugNews
We are here to help now