J&J and Doctors Differ in Opinion on DePuy Attune Knee Safety

Friday, January 5, 2018
Depuy Attune Knee

The rate of knee replacement surgeries each year in the United States has tripled in recent decades to almost 750,000 annually, and the number is expected to continue growing to roughly 3.5 million procedures over the next decade.

Without defects, infection or an accident, knee implants can last up to 20 years and have failure rates of less than 2%. However, doctors recently uncovered a trend of early failure in one of the most popular knee implant models: the DePuy Synthes Attune.

Ironically, the news comes just after DePuy parent company Johnson & Johnson lauded the results of a British study suggesting Attune knees were less likely to fail than the industry average. Now, doctors and thousands of patients are questioning whether the Attune is truly a safe implant and if DePuy sold it knowing the risks.

J&J Claims Attune Among the Safest

Last May, DePuy Synthes celebrated the results of a four-year study of more than 10,000 patients who had received Attune knee implants in the United Kingdom based on data from the National Joint Registry.

The findings, introduced at the annualEuropean Federation National Associationsof Orthopedics &Traumatology Congress inVienna, showed the number of patients needing revision surgeries within 4 years of implant were only 1.3%, compared to an average of 1.9% for all knee implants.

That suggested the Attune implants may be 31% less likely to experience early failure.

Orthopedic Surgeons Report Attune Knee Failures

Within a week of the U.K study release, a group of doctors published a report in theJournal of Knee Surgerytelling a drastically different story: Attune patients were experiencing a rash of failures due to implant de-bonding.

The report came on June 7th, when a group of 9 prominent joint surgeons from New York to Washington State published their findings.

According to the paper, doctors began reporting problems with de-bonding, or devices becoming unglued from tibial bone attachments, as early as 2013 when the Attune was first introduced.

Overall, the group of physicians said they had noticed a higher rate of implant de-bonding among Attune knee patients than normal. In some cases, the implant was found to have never connected to the lower leg bones at all.

Based on the conflicting reports, it is difficult to determine if the Attune knee implant is safer or more likely to fail than similar devices. However, it is clear that J&J has known of the problems since 2013 without adding warnings for consumers.

Side Effects of Attune Knee De-bonding

Those patients who experience de-bonding of their Attune knee implants may suffer severe side effects, such as:

  • Consistent pain
  • Lost stability
  • Reduced range of motion
  • Swelling or inflammation
  • Knee moving sideways or backwards

These could be signals of an unattached knee implant, which can make standing or walking very difficult. Since an estimated 70,000 or more patients have received an Attune knee, experts are concerned that thousands may experience de-bonding.

Unfortunately, the only way to correct these problems is with invasive surgery to replace the device.

Lawsuits Filed For Attune Knee Failures

Last year, lawyers began new litigation against J&J/DePuy Synthes for those patients who suffered Attune knee failure, based on the companys failure to warn of the risks.

Anyone who received an implant since 2013 and has experienced symptoms of de-bonding should talk with their doctor. They should also speak with a lawyer that can review their medical records to determine their rights.

Those affected may be entitled to substantial compensation. Contact DrugNews today for more information or to talk directly with a lawyer.


Perriello, B. J&Js DePuy Synthes touts 4-year Attune knee revision data.Mass Device. (May 31, 2017). Retrieved fromhttp://www.massdevice.com/jjs-depuy-synthes-touts-4-year-attune-knee-data/

Bonutti, P. et al. Unusually High Rate of Early Failure of Tibial Component in ATTUNE Total Knee Arthroplasty System at ImplantCement Interface. The Journal of Knee Surgery. (June 7, 2017). Retrieved fromhttps://www.thieme-connect.com/DOI/DOI?10.1055/s-0037-1603756

Depuy Attune
Total Knee
Side Effects

Other drugs and devices in the news:

Tuesday, April 14, 2020
Sudden Rise in Elmiron Eye Disease Cases Raises Questions

Elmiron is a mild blood-thinner drug that has been around since 1996 and is prescribed to treat bladder pain or inflammation, a condition called interstitial cystitis.

Monday, April 13, 2020
Asbestos Mesothelioma
Estimated $30 Billion Left Unclaimed in Asbestos Victim Funds

Since many of the companies that sold asbestos or used it in their products have long since gone out of business, people who are diagnosed with asbestos-related cancers often think it’s too late to file a lawsuit.

Get in touch with us.

Call, email or live chat with us today to see how we can help.

call DrugNews.net
Need a quick answer? Call us!
email DrugNews.net
Reach out to us by email.
live chat with DrugNews
We are here to help now